Plagiarism Policy
The Shautuna: Jurnal Ilmiah Mahasiswa Perbandingan Mazhab maintains a strict zero-tolerance policy against plagiarism. Any form of plagiarism identified in a manuscript submitted to the journal will be addressed in accordance with the journal’s publication ethics and editorial policies.
Plagiarism is defined as the use or close imitation of the language, ideas, or intellectual work of others without proper acknowledgment and presenting such work as one’s own. All submitted manuscripts must be original, unpublished, and not under consideration elsewhere. Any material taken verbatim from another source must be clearly identified through appropriate quotation marks, indentation where applicable, and proper citation. Authors must credit the original source of reused text and graphics and obtain written permission from the copyright holder where required.
All submitted manuscripts are screened for similarity using Turnitin. Similarity reports are interpreted qualitatively and contextually by the managing editor in consultation with the editorial team, considering legitimate similarities such as references, quotations, legal texts, methodological descriptions, and commonly used phrases.
As a general guideline (not an automatic decision rule), the journal applies the following similarity ranges:
- Similarity index above 40% may indicate extensive overlap and will normally result in rejection due to unacceptable levels of similarity, subject to editorial review.
- Similarity index from 20% through 40% may require substantial revisions. Authors may be required to improve citation practices and enhance paraphrasing in the affected sections.
- Similarity index below 20% is generally considered acceptable, although minor revisions related to citation or paraphrasing may still be required.
In cases requiring revision, authors must resubmit the revised manuscript together with an updated similarity report demonstrating that all concerns have been adequately addressed. Final editorial decisions are based on both the similarity assessment and scholarly judgment, in accordance with the journal’s ethical standards.