Authorship and Contributorship
Every person named as an author of an Al-Daulah article made a real contribution, and we credit every real contribution.
This policy sets out the requirements for authorship and contributorship so that contributions to published work are attributed clearly. As an open-access journal publishing under a Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY 4.0) license, Al-Daulah lets authors retain the copyright of their articles while granting broad permission for distribution and reuse.
The journal follows the principles of transparency and best practice in scholarly publishing set out by:
COPE DOAJ OASPA WAME
In particular, it follows the Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
Authorship is based on substantial contributions to the conception, design, execution, or interpretation of the research. To be listed as an author, a person must meet all three criteria:
| Substantial contribution | A significant contribution to the intellectual content of the article, such as conceiving or designing the study, acquiring, analyzing, or interpreting data, or drafting or critically revising the manuscript. |
| Approval of the final version | Approval of the final version of the article and agreement to take responsibility for its content. |
| Accountability | The ability to explain and defend the research and its findings in public if required. |
Honorary (gift) authorship, naming someone who did not contribute, and ghost authorship, leaving out someone who did, are not acceptable in Al-Daulah. The journal actively works to prevent and address both.
|
Listed as an author
Anyone who meets all three authorship criteria. |
Acknowledged, not listed
Anyone who made only minor contributions to the research or the article, named in the Acknowledgments. |
To promote transparency and avoid misunderstanding, every manuscript includes a CRediT Authorship Contribution Statement in its back matter, as provided in the journal template. The statement identifies each author’s contribution using the CRediT taxonomy, for example:
Conceptualization Methodology Investigation Formal analysis Writing – original draft Writing – review & editing Supervision
The statement is published with the article and must accurately reflect the role each author played.
Requests to add, remove, or reorder authors after submission are considered only in exceptional circumstances.
| 1 | Written request. All authors involved send a written explanation giving the detailed reasons for the change. |
| 2 | Evaluation. The editorial board evaluates the request carefully, consulting the journal’s advisers and COPE guidance where necessary. |
| 3 | Decision. The authors are informed whether the change is accepted. |
When authors disagree about authorship, the editorial board follows a structured process to investigate and resolve the matter. The parties are asked to provide evidence of their contributions, and the journal may seek guidance from COPE or other relevant organizations to ensure a fair and impartial outcome.
The journal does not become involved in, and is not liable for, personal disputes between authors.
Conflicts of interest. Authors disclose any potential conflict of interest that could influence the interpretation of their research, including financial interests, affiliations, or personal relationships, in the Declaration of Competing Interests. The journal encourages full transparency in these disclosures.
Ethical guidelines. Authors follow the journal’s Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement and the ethical standards of their field. This includes obtaining permission to use copyrighted material and obtaining informed consent from research participants.










