Data and Reproducibility

Readers should be able to trace every finding in an Al-Daulah article back to its sources, data, and methods.

Al-Daulah is committed to transparency and rigor in scholarly research. This policy sets out the journal’s approach to data availability, reporting standards, and reproducibility, applied in ways that suit each type of legal and social research.

The journal follows the Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), including its principles on data and reproducibility.
What to provide, by type of research

Authors describe their data collection, methodology, and analysis in enough detail for others to verify the results.

Doctrinal and normative research Cite primary legal sources precisely: statutes and regulations with their number, year, and article; court decisions with their case number and date; and fatwas or classical texts with the edition used. Link to official versions where available.
Empirical qualitative research Describe the data sources, the selection of informants, and the methods of collection and analysis. Provide representative excerpts, such as interview quotations, to support the findings, while protecting participants’ identities.
Quantitative research Deposit datasets in a reputable data repository, or provide a link to the data in the article. If data cannot be shared for ethical or legal reasons, explain why and state how the journal and readers can request access.
Data Availability statement

The journal encourages authors to make all data underlying their findings available to readers. Every article includes a Data Availability statement in its back matter, as provided in the journal template. Examples:

Data openly available The data supporting the findings of this study are openly available in [repository name] at https://doi.org/[DOI].
Data available on request Data will be made available on request.
Data cannot be shared The interview data cannot be shared publicly to protect the confidentiality of research participants.
No new data No new data were created or analyzed in this study; all sources are cited in the article.
Reporting guidelines and reproducibility

Reporting guidelines. Authors are encouraged to follow reporting guidelines suited to their study design, such as COREQ or SRQR for interview-based qualitative research. These guidelines make research easier for readers, reviewers, and editors to evaluate and to reproduce.

Reproducibility. Manuscripts give enough detail on methodology, protocols, and analytical approach for other researchers to reproduce the findings. Where needed, the journal may ask authors for access to the raw data.

Data citation

Datasets and sources used in the research are cited properly to give credit and allow attribution. Data citations follow the journal’s citation style (Chicago Manual of Style, 17th edition, full note) and appear in the footnotes and the reference list, with a DOI or stable link where available.

Compliance check

The editors and peer reviewers assess adherence to this policy during manuscript evaluation. Authors may be asked to provide additional information or clarification about data availability and reporting.

Review of this policy. This policy is reviewed periodically and updated to reflect evolving best practice in data sharing, reporting, and reproducibility. The journal notifies authors of any revisions and publishes them on the journal website.