Conflicts of Interest

Everyone involved in publishing an Al-Daulah article declares any interest that could affect, or appear to affect, their judgment.

Al-Daulah is committed to the highest standards of transparency and ethical conduct in scholarly publishing. This policy defines conflicts of interest and explains how the journal handles them for authors, reviewers, editors, and the publisher, whether identified before or after publication.

What is a conflict of interest?
A conflict of interest arises when a person or organization has financial, personal, professional, or academic relationships or interests that could influence, or be perceived to influence, their objectivity, integrity, or decisions in research, review, editing, or publishing.
Types of conflict to disclose

All potential conflicts relevant to the work must be disclosed. They include, but are not limited to:

Financial interests Funding sources, shareholdings, employment, consultancies, or other financial relationships related to the research.
Personal relationships Close personal relationships or family ties with people involved in the research or the publication process.
Academic relationships Collaborations or academic affiliations that may affect objectivity or create a perception of bias.
Competing affiliations Affiliations with organizations that have a competing interest in the research or its outcome.
Intellectual property Patents, copyrights, or other intellectual property rights that could be affected by the research or its publication.
Responsibilities by role

The journal handles every conflict of interest with diligence and transparency.

Authors Disclose all potential conflicts of interest at submission, in the Declaration of Competing Interests. Report any conflict identified after publication promptly to the editors and address it transparently.
Reviewers Decline an invitation to review when a conflict of interest could affect their impartiality. If a reviewer becomes aware of a conflict during the review, they inform the editors immediately, and the editors take appropriate action.
Editors and journal staff Recuse themselves from handling any submission in which they have a conflict of interest. In case of doubt, the editorial board decides how the case is handled.
Publisher Maintains policies to manage conflicts of interest within its organization and ensures that editorial decisions are not influenced by financial considerations or other competing interests.
When editors or reviewers are authors. Editors, editorial board members, and reviewers who submit their own manuscripts to Al-Daulah are excluded from every stage of handling those manuscripts. Their submissions are assigned to an independent editor and go through the same double-blind peer review as all others.
Transparency and disclosure

Authors’ disclosures are published with their articles in the Declaration of Competing Interests, which is part of the back matter of the journal template. If there is nothing to declare, the statement reads, for example:

The authors declare that they have no competing financial interests or personal relationships that could influence the work reported in this paper.

Conflicts declared by reviewers and editors are recorded by the editorial office and taken into account when manuscripts are assigned, so that the confidentiality of double-blind review is preserved.

Review of this policy. This policy is reviewed periodically to keep it effective and in line with best practice. The journal communicates any revisions to stakeholders and publishes them on the journal website.