Retraction, Withdrawal, and Correction Policy

Al-Daulah keeps its published record accurate and trustworthy, so readers can rely on every article in its archive.

Authors work hard to prepare their manuscripts and go through the journal’s peer review. Occasionally, however, a published article must be corrected, withdrawn, or retracted, for example, when an error is discovered or when the article is found to breach publication ethics. In such cases, the journal may issue a correction, clarification, retraction, or apology. Each case is handled under strict criteria to preserve confidence in the journal’s electronic archive and the completeness of the scholarly record used by researchers and librarians.

This policy follows the COPE Retraction Guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics and the journal’s Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement.

At a glance

Action When it applies What happens to the article
Retraction Serious breach of research or publication ethics, or a serious error that undermines the article Stays online, marked “retracted”, with a retraction notice
Withdrawal An early version contains an error, the article was submitted twice, or the author recognizes an ethical breach Withdrawn on the author’s written statement to the editorial board
Correction A small part of an otherwise reliable article is flawed, or the author list is wrong Stays online; an erratum, corrigendum, or addendum is published
Removal Legal reasons, such as defamation or a court order Text removed; title and authors kept with a removal notice
Replacement The original, if acted upon, could pose a serious risk Retracted and linked to a corrected, republished version
Article retraction

An article is retracted when it is found to breach scientific or ethical codes. Retraction may also be used when a serious error in submission or publication undermines the article. A retraction may be initiated by the author or by the editor, on the advice of the editorial board. Grounds for retraction include:

Duplicate submission False claims of authorship Fake authors Plagiarism Fraudulent use of data

Before publication
The editor returns the manuscript to the author with a retraction letter from the Editor-in-Chief.
After publication
The article page opens with a retraction notice before the reader can proceed to the article. The PDF is kept unchanged except for a “Retracted” watermark on every page, and the HTML version is removed.

Retraction process

1 Concern raised. The article is brought to the attention of the editor.
2 Investigation. The editor follows the relevant COPE flowchart step by step, including obtaining and evaluating the authors’ response.
3 Editorial board review. Before any decision, the editor’s report goes to the editorial board, which advises on the ethical issues to ensure a consistent approach.
4 Decision. The final decision is sent to the authors and, where necessary, to other relevant bodies such as their institution.
5 Publication of the notice. The retraction statement is posted online and published in the next available issue.
Article withdrawal

An article may be withdrawn when its initial version contains an error, or when it was accidentally submitted twice to Al-Daulah or to another publisher.

Withdrawal may also follow a breach of the scientific code of ethics, such as duplicate submission, false claims of authorship, plagiarism, self-plagiarism, or fraudulent use of data. When authors become aware of such a breach, they may withdraw the article by sending a written statement of withdrawal to the editorial board of Al-Daulah.

Article correction

The journal considers issuing a correction when:

  • a small part of an otherwise reliable article reports flawed data or proves misleading, especially as the result of an honest error; or
  • the author list is incorrect, for example, a deserving author has been omitted, or someone who does not meet the authorship criteria has been included.

Corrections to peer-reviewed content take one of three forms:

Erratum
Publisher correction
Notifies readers of a significant error made by the journal staff, usually in production, that harms the publication record, the integrity of the article, or the reputation of the authors or the journal.
Corrigendum
Author correction
Notifies readers of a significant error made by the authors that harms the publication record, the integrity of the article, or the reputation of the authors or the journal.
Addendum
Author addition
An addition by the authors that explains inconsistencies, expands the existing work, or updates information in the article.

The editors decide whether a correction is needed, sometimes on the advice of reviewers or members of the editorial board. The handling editor asks the authors for clarification, but the final decision on whether a correction is required, and of which type, rests with the editors.

Article removal: legal limitations

In rare cases, an article may have to be removed from the journal’s online database. This happens only when the article is defamatory, is a hoax, infringes the legal rights of others, is subject to a court order, or poses a risk to state security. The metadata (title and authors) are kept, and the text is replaced by a notice stating that the article has been removed for legal reasons.

Article replacement

Where an article, if acted upon, might pose a serious risk, its authors may retract the flawed original and replace it with a corrected version. The retraction procedure is followed, but the retraction notice links to the corrected, republished article and shows the history of the document.

Reporting a concern. Authors who find an error in their published article, and readers who have concerns about a published article, are asked to contact the editorial office of Al-Daulah with a clear description of the issue.