Publication Ethics and Misconduct

Al-Daulah is committed to the highest standards of ethics in scholarly publishing, shared by its authors, reviewers, editors, and publisher.

This statement sets out the ethical conduct expected of everyone involved in publishing an article in Al-Daulah: Jurnal Hukum Pidana dan Ketatanegaraan- authors, editors, peer reviewers, and the publisher, the Faculty of Sharia and Law, Universitas Islam Negeri Alauddin Makassar.

This statement is based on the guidelines and core practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Where an issue is not covered here, the journal follows COPE guidance and flowcharts.

Responsibilities of each party

Editors
  • Publication decisions. The editors decide which submitted articles are published, guided by the policies of the editorial board and by the results of peer review. They are bound by the law on defamation, copyright infringement, and plagiarism.
  • Fair play. Manuscripts are evaluated on their intellectual content only, without regard to the authors’ position, race, gender, religion, ethnicity, citizenship, sexual orientation, or political views.
  • Confidentiality. Editors and editorial staff do not disclose information about a submitted manuscript to anyone other than the authors, reviewers, editorial advisers, and the publisher.
  • Use of unpublished material. Unpublished material in a submitted manuscript is not used in an editor’s own research without the author’s written consent. Information obtained through peer review is not used for personal advantage.
  • Conflicts of interest. Editors make decisions free of commercial or personal bias, and step aside from handling any manuscript in which they have a conflict of interest.
  • Integrity of the record. Editors respond to concerns about published work and, where needed, publish corrections, retractions, or expressions of concern.
Peer reviewers
  • Contribution to decisions. Reviewers assist the editors in making editorial decisions and help authors improve their manuscripts through double-blind peer review.
  • Promptness. Reviewers who feel unqualified, or who cannot complete the review on time, inform the editors promptly so that another reviewer can be invited.
  • Confidentiality. Manuscripts under review are confidential documents. They are not shown to or discussed with others without the editor’s permission, and information from the review process is not used for personal advantage.
  • Objectivity. Reviews are conducted objectively, with views expressed clearly and supported by arguments. Personal criticism of the authors is inappropriate.
  • Sources and plagiarism. Reviewers point out relevant published work that has not been cited, and alert the editors to any substantial similarity or overlap with other published work.
  • Conflicts of interest. Reviewers decline manuscripts in which they have a competitive, collaborative, or other relationship with the authors or institutions involved.
  • Accountability. Reviewers take full responsibility for their recommendations and work to improve the quality of the review process and its outcomes.
Authors
  • Reporting standards. Authors present original research or arguments that are systematic, honest, and accurate, free of plagiarism and of fabricated, falsified, or manipulated data.
  • Originality. Submitted work is entirely original, has not been published before, and is not under consideration elsewhere. The work and words of others are properly cited.
  • Multiple submission. Submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal at the same time is unethical and unacceptable.
  • Authorship. Authorship is limited to those who made a significant contribution to the work. All co-authors approve the final version, and each author’s role is stated in the CRediT Authorship Contribution Statement.
  • Disclosure. Authors declare any financial or personal conflicts of interest and all sources of funding.
  • Responsibility. Authors are responsible for the content of their articles and for any consequences arising from them, and follow the journal’s author guidelines.
  • Errors in published work. Authors who discover a significant error in their published article notify the editors promptly and cooperate to correct or retract it.
Publisher
  • Publication. The Faculty of Sharia and Law, Universitas Islam Negeri Alauddin Makassar, publishes articles that have passed editing, peer review, and layout in line with scholarly journal rules.
  • Editorial independence. The publisher safeguards the academic freedom of editors and reviewers and does not interfere in editorial decisions.
  • Protection. The publisher protects privacy, intellectual property, and copyright, and supports the editors in handling cases of misconduct.
  • Preservation. The publisher ensures the permanent availability of published articles through archiving.

Integrity policies

Plagiarism Submissions may be checked with similarity-detection software at any stage. Plagiarism in any form, including self-plagiarism and unacknowledged reuse of one’s own published text, leads to rejection or, after publication, retraction.
Duplicate and redundant publication Publishing substantially the same work in more than one outlet, or splitting one study into several articles without justification, is not permitted.
Research involving people Empirical studies that use interviews, surveys, or other data from people must obtain informed consent and protect participants’ identities. Authors state in the Methods section how they did this.
Generative AI AI tools cannot be listed as authors. Authors who use AI tools in preparing a manuscript disclose this and remain fully responsible for its accuracy and originality. Reviewers and editors do not upload manuscripts to AI tools.
Corrections and retractions Errors are corrected through published corrections. We retract articles with serious flaws or misconduct, and we link the retraction notice to the original article, following COPE retraction guidelines.
Complaints and appeals Authors may appeal an editorial decision, and anyone may raise a complaint about the journal, by writing to the editorial office with a clear explanation. An editor not involved in the original decision reviews each case.

How suspected misconduct is handled

Anyone may raise concerns about plagiarism, data fabrication, duplicate publication, authorship disputes, or other misconduct at any stage through the journal’s editorial office.

1 Initial assessment
The editors examine the concern and the available evidence, in confidence.
2 Author response
The authors are informed of the concern and given the opportunity to respond.
3 Decision
Following the relevant COPE flowchart, the editors decide on the outcome: no action, rejection, correction, an expression of concern, or retraction.
4 Follow-up
Where serious misconduct is confirmed, the editors may inform the authors’ institution and take further action in line with COPE guidance.
By submitting a manuscript to Al-Daulah, authors agree to follow this statement. Reviewers and editors accept it when they take on a review or an editorial assignment.