Improving Compliance towards International Humanitarian Law: Filling in the Gaps?
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24252/al-daulah.v13i1.48847Keywords:
International Humanitarian Law, Compliance, Armed ConflictAbstract
Research Objective: This study evaluates existing International Humanitarian Law compliance mechanisms, identifies implementation gaps, and assesses factors influencing adherence by states and non-state armed groups in conflict situations. Research Methodology: The research employs qualitative methodological approaches through case study analysis and comprehensive literature review to systematically evaluate IHL compliance mechanisms and factors affecting adherence. Results: The research identifies deficiencies in IHL enforcement systems, cultural barriers to implementation, and limitations in engaging non-state actors as primary impediments to compliance. Findings and Implications: The findings demonstrate systemic enforcement deficiencies, cultural impediments, and limited non-state actor engagement hindering effective IHL implementation, implying the need for more holistic approaches to enhance compliance across diverse conflict contexts. Conclusion: Despite providing a comprehensive legal framework to protect civilians during armed conflicts, persistent non-compliance undermines IHL's effectiveness and credibility, necessitating a multidisciplinary approach addressing legal, political, cultural, and operational factors. Contribution: This research contributes by advocating multidisciplinary approaches to enhance compliance, proposing implementation strengthening mechanisms, highlighting stakeholder roles, and developing a conceptual framework for holistic compliance systems. Limitations: From an academic perspective, the qualitative methodology employed presents inherent limitations in statistical generalizability. The absence of quantitative metrics makes it difficult to measure compliance levels objectively across different contexts. Additionally, case study approaches, while providing depth, naturally restrict the breadth of analytical scope, potentially overlooking unique implementation dynamics in unexamined conflict scenarios. Suggestions: The study recommends establishing permanent platforms for regular IHL discourse, enhancing institutional support, integrating cultural sensitivity, strengthening Red Cross/Red Crescent societies, involving NGOs in IHL dissemination, and facilitating stakeholder interactions. Future research should expand empirical scope through quantitative analyses and broader case studies
References
Abū Zakariyā Muḥī Al-Dīn Ibn Nuhās, Mashāri‘ Al-Ashwāq Ilaā Maṣāri‘ Al-Ushāq (Beirut: Dār al-Bashā’ir al-Islamiyyah, 1990).
Ahmed Al-Dawoody, IHL and Islamic Law in Contemporary Armed Conflict: Expert Workshop, Geneva 29-30 October 2018 (Genev, 2019), p. 13 <https://www.icrc.org/en/document/eyperts-workshop-report-ihl-and-islamic-law-contemporary-armed-conflicts>.
Al-Dawoody; Peter Maurer, ‘International Conference on Islam and IHL - Statement by the ICRC’, ICRC, 2016 <https://www.icrc.org/en/document/speech-icrc-president-international-conference-islam-and-ihl> [accessed 22 November 2018].
Andrew Bartles-Smith, ‘Religion and International Humanitarian Law’, International Review of the Red Cross, 104.920–921 (2022).
Antony Anghie, ‘Towards a Postcolonial International Law’, in Critical International Law: Post-Realism, Post Colonialism, and Transnationalism, ed. by Prabakhar Singh and Benoit Mayer (Oxford–New Delhi: Oxford University Press, 2014).
Antony Anghie, Imperialism, Sovereignty, and the Making of International Law (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2004).
Australia, Law of Armed Conflict, Commanders’ Guide, Australian Defence Force Publication, Operations Series, ADFP 37 Supplement 1: Interim Edition, 7 March 1994.
Australia, The Manual of the Law of Armed Conflict, Australian Defence Doctrine Publication 06.4, Australian Defence Headquarters, 11 May 2006.
Awn Shawkat Al-Khasawneh, ‘Islam and International Law’, in Islam and International Law: Engaging Self-Centrism from a Plurality of Perspectives, ed. by Müller Frick M-L (Leiden: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2013);
C. G. Weeramantry, Islamic Jurisprudence An International Perspective (Kuala Lumpur: The Other Press, 2001).
Canada, The Law of Armed Conflict at the Operational and Tactical Level, Office of the Judge Advocate General, 1999.
D. R. Atkins, 2007, Customary International Humanitarian Law and Multinational Military Operations in Malaysia.
Eva Wortel, ‘Humanitarians and Their Moral Stance in War: The Underlying Values’, International Review of the Red Cross, 91.876 (2009), 779–802.
Fajri Matahati Muhammadin and Ahmad Sadzali, ‘The International Criminal Court and Traditional Islamic Legal Scholarship: Analyzing the War Crimes Against Civilians’, in International Criminal Law-A Counter-Hegemonic Project?, ed. by Florian Jeßberger, Leonie Steinl, and Kalika Mehta (TMC. Asser Press and Springer, 2022).
Fajri Matahati Muhammadin and Fairuz El-Mechwar, ‘Masyumi’s" Djihad Dan Qitaal" and Islamic Laws of War: Ahead of Its Time?’, AL-IHKAM: Jurnal Hukum & Pranata Sosial, 18.2 (2023), 320–41;
Fajri Matahati Muhammadin and Shania Dwini Azzahra, ‘The Role of Fiqh Al-Siyar in International Law-Making: Escaping the Lethargy’, Al-Jami’ah: Journal of Islamic Studies, 60.2 (2022), 509–46;
Fajri Matahati Muhammadin and Thara Kunarti Wahab, ‘Fiqh Al-Jihād in Modern Warfare: Analyzing Prospects and Challenges with Reference to International Humanitarian Law’, IIUM Law Journal, 26.2 (2018), 241–74.
Fajri Matahati Muhammadin, ‘Fiqh Al-Jihād In The Contemporary World: Addressing the Gaps in the Regulations on the Means and Methods of Warfare’ (Ph.D Thesis, International Islamic University of Malaysia, 2020).
Fajri Matahati Muhammadin, ‘The United Nations’ Beirut Declaration and Its 18 Commitments on Faith for Rights’: A Critique From An Islamic Perspective’, IIUM Law Journal, 28.1 (2020), 73–112.
G. Porretto and S. Vite, The application of international humanitarian law and human rights law to international organisations, Research Paper Series, 2006, at 61-62.
H. Jo, 2016, Compliance with International Humanitarian Law by Non-State Armed Groups: How Can It Be Improved?, Yearbook of International Humanitarian Law Volume 19.
https://blogs.icrc.org/law-and-policy/2018/12/14/strengthening-compliance-with-ihl-disappointment-and-hope/ (accessed on 14 March 2023).
https://casebook.icrc.org/law/criminal-repression (accessed on 17 March 2023)
https://lieber.westpoint.edu/improving-compliance-ihl-long-term-enterprise/ (accessed on 14 March 2023)
https://www.genevacall.org/dr-congo-child-soldiers-leave-armed-actors-following-geneva-calls-awareness-raising-efforts/ (accessed on 18 February 2023)
https://www.genevacall.org/sudan-sudan-peoples-liberation-movement-north-neutralizes-211-stockpiled-anti-personnel-mines/ (accessed on 18 February 2023)
https://www.ihffc.org/index.asp?page=statesparties_list (accessed on 15 March 2023)
https://www.justsecurity.org/82750/lets-talk-about-compliance-with-international-human-law/ (accessed on 18 March 2023)
https://www.justsecurity.org/82750/lets-talk-about-compliance-with-international-human-law/ (accessed on 18 March 2023).
https://www.justsecurity.org/82750/lets-talk-about-compliance-with-international-human-law/ (accessed on 18 March 2023).
ICRC, Twelve Issues for 2022: What States can do to Improve Respect for International Law, 21 March 2022.
ICRC, Twelve Issues for 2022: What States can do to Improve Respect for International Law, 21 March 2022.
Indonesia, The Basics of International Humanitarian Law in Air Warfare, Indonesian Air Force, 1990.
International Humanitarian Law Research Initiative, International Humanitarian Law Research Initiative, Improving Compliance with International Humanitarian Law by International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), Background Paper prepared for Informal High-Level Expert Meeting on Current Challenges to International Humanitarian Law, Cambridge, 25-27 June 2004.
Israel, Rules of Warfare on the Battlefield, Military Advocate-General’s Corps Command, IDF School of Military Law, Second Edition, 2006.
J. A. Stanton, 2016, Violence and Restraint in Civil War: Civilian Targeting in the Shadow of International Law.
J. L. Dunoff, et. al., 2005, International Law: Norms, Actors, and Processes.
J. Pejic, 2016, Strengthening compliance with IHL: The ICRC-Swiss initiative, International Review of the Red Cross 98.
J. S. Pictet (ed.), 1952, Commentary on the First Geneva Convention, ICRC.
Julie Fraser, ‘A Seat at the Table: Islamic Law’s Neglected Potential in Universalising International Humanitarian Law’, in Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law: Challenges Ahead, ed. by Norman Weiss and Andreas Zimmermann (Edward Elgar Publishing, 2022);
K. Thynne, 2019, Implementation of International Humanitarian Law in Southeast Asia: Challenges in the Prevention of Violations.
Mohamed Elewa Badar, ‘Islamic Law (Shari’a) and the Jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court’, Leiden Journal of International Law, 24 (2011), 411–33 (pp. 412–14).
Mohsen Al Attar, ‘Reframing the “Universality” of International Law in a Globalizing World’, McGill Law Journal, 59.1 (2013), 95–139;
Muḥammad ibn Aḥmad ibn Abi Sahl Al-Sarakhsī, Sharḥ Al-Siyār Al-Kabīr (Egypt: Al-Shirkah al-Sharqiyyah li l-I‘lānāt, 1971).
N. Melzer, 2016, International Humanitarian Law: A Comprehensive Introduction, ICRC.
Nesrine Badawi, ‘Regulation of Armed Conflict: Critical Comparativism’, Third World Quarterly, 37.11 (2016), 1990–2009.
Obiora Chinedu Okafor, ‘Critical Third World Approaches to International Law (TWAIL): Theory, Methodology, or Both?’, International Community Law Review, 10.4 (2008), 371–78;
Salim Farrar, ‘The Organisation of Islamic Cooperation: Forever on the Periphery of Public International Law?’, Chinese Journal of International Law, 13.4 (2014), 787–817.
South Africa, Advanced Law of Armed Conflict Teaching Manual, School of Military Justice, 1 April 2008, as amended to 25 October 2013.
The Netherlands, Humanitair Oorlogsrecht: Handleiding, Voorschift No. 27-412, Koninklijke Landmacht, Militair Juridische Dienst, 2005;
United States, Field Manual 27-10, The Law of Land Warfare, US Department of the Army, 18 July 1956, as modified by Change No. 1, 15 July 1976.
UNSC, Protection of civilians in armed conflict: Report of the Secretary-General, S/2022/381, 10 May 2022.
UNSC, Protection of civilians in armed conflict: Report of the Secretary-General, S/2022/381, 10 May 2022.
UNSC, Statement by the President of the Security Council, S/PRST/2013/2, 12 February 2013;
Zezen Zainal Mutaqin, ‘Restraining Violence in the Classical Islamic Juristic Discourses’ (unpublished SJD Dissertation, University of California, 2021).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Fitry Nabiilah Hamidah, Fajri Matahati Muhammadin
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
The authors of a work hold the copyright and grant the Al-Daulah: Jurnal Hukum Pidana dan Ketatanegaraan the right of first publication. The work is also licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which enables others to share the work while acknowledging the authorship and initial publication in the journal. The authors can make separate contractual agreements for the non-exclusive distribution of the published version of the work, such as by posting it to an institutional repository or editing it for a book, with an acknowledgment of its initial publication in this journal. Authors are allowed and encouraged to post their work online, such as in institutional repositories or on their website, before and during the submission process. This can lead to productive exchanges and greater citation of the published work.
